PR Firms Shun "Pay For Performance" but Have a Blind Spot When the Table is Turned

By Sandy -
Over the years I have often heard how "pay for performance" is a wrong, even harmful way to do business.  It's an argument that still goes on today.  I read this post very good post by Scott Robertson today on LinkedIn and it got a little annoyed at how the PR agency business doesn't apply this good sense to the recruiting industry.  Here is the comment I left after reading the article:


In 20 years 99% of the agencies I’ve worked with agree with you.  Then why don't they realize the same is true of a recruiter. Pay for performance (in my business it's called "contingency search" is all they want. Yet the same three fundamental flaws apply:

1. Promising results that are out of your control:  We can present the absolute best candidates but it's dangerous to promise the hire will be made. The candidates decides not to move, their own firm makes a counter offer, etc.

2. Devalues expert advice and counsel: With a pay for performance attitude, the client does not really commit to the recruiter.  The agency doesn’t build a relationship of trust and understanding which would result in more refined research and well vetted candidates.  Other search firms are used so judgment and discretion goes out the window in the hopes that you’ll get lucky -- so you refer many people.  On the other hand, the advice of your recruiter could provide you with important information about the candidate market. 


3.  Makes the recruiting process tactical: Same thing here, exactly.  Yet everyone knows that making a good match includes intangibles like chemistry, insight, personality, clicking, and a little magic.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sr. Manager - Employee Communications - B2B - NJ

By Sandy -
We have an exciting new role for an Employee Communications Manager working with a global professional services company headquartered in New Jersey.  This is an ideal position for a candidate who can deliver engaging, professional and impactful communications materials across a variety of channels, while developing his/her skills in strategic communications.  The successful candidate will be well-versed in employee communications trends and best practices, particularly in digital communications, video, and social media, and can support existing company vehicles as well as bring new ideas on modern content and delivery. About 5 to 7 years of experience doing this in a B2B or professional services environment is required. Please Contact:  Jackie Mets at:   jackie@charet.com
Read more

Strategic Marketing Manager - Professional Services Firm - NYC

By Sandy -
The Strategic Marketing Manager is responsible for developing and implementing various strategic marketing campaigns and related initiatives in support of the Firm’s brand positioning, business development and recruitment objectives. Guided by the Firm’s global communications strategy, he or she supports the Global Marketing Communications Director and key stakeholders in ensuring the efficient and effective execution of marketing communications strategies and campaigns.  Duties and Accountabilities:  Marketing Strategy and Initiatives  • Focus on creation of an integrated marketing communications strategy using a selection and mix of various tactics and approaches to achieve the business goals  • Manage awareness/perception and market insight research to inform ongoing marketing communications strategy and campaign development to contribute to the development of the brand strategy and ensure it supports evolving business and client needs  • Work with the Global Marketing Commu
Read more

Vice President - Senior Strategist

By Sandy -
VP -  Senior  Strategist       My client  is a leading U.S. strategic communications firm that produces  S ustainability/ ESG reports  and  A nnual  Shareholder R eports for Fortune 500 clients.   Their  client partners include some of the most well-known corporate names and brands in the U.S., including Wal-Mart, General Motors, UPS, Caterpillar, Mohawk Industries, Entergy, MassMutual, Delta Airlines, The Campbell Soup Company and Hilton.     This creative firm  specializes in offering a  turn-key solution s  to produce creative and compelling stakeholder communications that meet clients’ strategic objectives. These long-form communication vehicles range from a few pages to tens of thousands of words in length, in both digital and print formats.  The  work encompasses research,  disclosure strategy,  writing, design, interactive development, print production and more.      The firm has  expanded its service  beyond its traditional  reporting  niche to offer a more comprehensive range
Read more